Oct2022
FootballGS ReportGSHUBSports GSHUBClyde Edwards-Helaire #25 of the Kansas City Chiefs runs past Mike Edwards #32 of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers during an NFL football game at Raymond James Stadium on October 2, 2022 in Tampa, Florida.
You are here:

The NFL's most confusing backfields: Trust or Bust?

Confused about these backfields? Say less. We’ve got your back.

Clyde Edwards-Helaire #25 of the Kansas City Chiefs runs past Mike Edwards #32 of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers during an NFL football game at Raymond James Stadium on October 2, 2022 in Tampa, Florida.
Photo by Kevin Sabitus/Getty Images

We’re four weeks into the NFL season, and there are still several backfields that have us pulling out our hair on a weekly basis. We’re here to help limit the damage — to your beautiful head of hair, your fantasy teams, and your NFL bets rest-of-season.

Which running backs should you trust… and who’s set to bust? Let’s dive in.

 

Jaguars: Travis Etienne Jr. vs. James Robinson

This one? It hurt. We (and the Jaguars, FWIW) went all-in on Travis Etienne Jr. despite some stellar play from UDFA James Robinson, and now it’s come back to bite us. Robinson is in the midst of his own campaign for Comeback Player of the Year following a ruptured Achilles tendon, and the team wasted NO TIME getting him back into his workhorse role. In Week 4, however, we saw a shift, with Robinson playing a season-low 47% of offensive snaps. Is this the sign that the Jaguars are ready for their former first-round RB to carry the load?

Who we trust: We’re still rolling with James Robinson. Gaming Society’s own Tony Cavallo is the OG believer in the Robinson comeback, and he hit it on the head. Despite a decreased snap share in Week 4, we’re going to chalk that up to the fact that they were playing from behind and Etienne profiles as their third-down back. J-Rob has established himself as the team’s clear goalline option (having received four carries inside the five to Etienne’s ZERO!) and usage should trend back up against a more-evenly matched opponent in Week 5.

The Texans are allowing a league-high 141 rushing yards to running backs PER GAME! Smash the over on Robinson’s rushing yards this week???

 

Bucs: Leonard Fournette vs. Rachaad White

If you were like us, you may have been literally screaming at your TV watching Rachaad White steal way-too-many Tom Brady targets on Sunday Night Football. Fournette is averaging just 3.7 yards per carry this season (ouch) and ranks 71st out of 93 running backs with 2.37 yards after contact per attempt. Simply put — we need playoff Lenny back ASAP. Should the emergence of White as a receiver be concerning for Fournette managers?

Who we trust: Leonard Fournette… sort of. The Bucs are in a position of needing help at the receiver from anyone (and any position) they can get, so I’m not ready to panic about White’s usage just yet. The Bucs gave Fournette a 3-year, $21 million contract extension, so we can’t expect him to be on the outs just yet.

The real question is — can you trust any running backs behind this obliterated offensive line? Maybe not. We might need to temper expectations for Fournette’s efficiency, but he should still be the guy to see the bulk of the rush attempts for the foreseeable future.

 

Jets: Breece Hall vs. Michael Carter

Remember that one time we took Breece Hall in the third round of our fantasy drafts just to watch second-year Michael Carter GO ABSOLUTELY OFF? Yeah… we do too. Leading into Week 4, plugging Hall into your lineup (or betting on his player props) felt like a risky little game we didn’t want to be playing. Carter had seen the bulk of touches for the team at running back prior to Week 4… but did we see the tides turn?

Who we trust: Breece Hall. He’s seen an increase in offensive snaps in three-straight weeks, while Carter has seen a decrease in his snap share in four-straight weeks. The Jets drafted Hall No. 36 overall, and it looks as though they’re looking to generate more touches for him. Ride the wave!

 

Chiefs: Clyde Edwards-Helaire vs. Isiah Pacheco

Clyde Edwards-Helaire can’t seriously be on pace for 21 touchdowns on just 13.5 touches per game… right? It would be the most CEH thing ever if he finally went off just as we all gave up hope in the former LSU product. There’s just one wrinkle in the mix, however — and that’s rookie RB Isiah Pacheco, who was everyone’s favorite training camp darling. He’s averaging a cool 5.0 yards per rush attempt and looks so good when he touches the ball. It’s the infrequency of those touches that are the problem, however.

Who we trust: Clyde Edwards-Helaire. Isiah Pacheco might be one of the most exciting seventh-round picks we’ve seen in some time, but he has yet to see more than 17 offensive snaps in a game. It’s the CEH show for now… and why wouldn’t be if this guy keeps averaging more than a touchdown per game?

Related Articles

6 reasons to watch NBA preseason

Preseason games aren’t as meaningless as you think.

Never miss a thing

Stay informed and entertained, for free